For a UK sole trader comparing Cuppa vs QuickFile, both support MTD for Income Tax, but they price differently: Cuppa's bookkeeping is free with a low-cost Pro plan for filing, while QuickFile is free up to a usage limit.
The practical difference is product scope. Cuppa is built around one workflow: record income and expenses as a sole trader and submit quarterly to HMRC. QuickFile is a full small-business bookkeeping platform with invoicing, purchase orders, VAT, multi-user access, and more.
For a simple sole-trader operation, that extra capability is mostly overhead. For a business with more moving parts, QuickFile's depth is an asset.
Key Takeaways
- Cuppa's Free plan covers bookkeeping; Pro at £6/month (£59/year) adds HMRC filing. QuickFile is free up to 1,000 nominal ledger entries per 12 months.
- Cuppa is designed exclusively for sole traders. QuickFile targets small to medium businesses broadly.
- QuickFile has more bookkeeping features. Cuppa has a simpler workflow.
- Both are HMRC-recognised and support MTD for Income Tax quarterly submissions.
Choose Cuppa or QuickFile?
Choose Cuppa if:
- You want the simplest possible sole-trader MTD workflow
- You prefer a tool designed specifically for self-employed UK sole traders
- You have straightforward income and expenses with no complex accounting needs
- You want to start free and pay a low-cost Pro plan only when you're ready to file
Choose QuickFile if:
- You need full double-entry bookkeeping capabilities
- You have multiple users (staff or accountants) who need access
- You are VAT-registered and want VAT return filing included
- You want purchase orders, delivery notes, and more traditional accounting features
Neither is ideal if:
- You need payroll, project accounting, or multi-currency payroll
- You run a limited company with complex reporting requirements
Cuppa vs QuickFile at a Glance
| Criteria | Cuppa | QuickFile |
|---|---|---|
| Product style | Sole-trader MTD workflow app | Small-business bookkeeping platform |
| Target user | UK sole traders | SMBs, sole traders, accountants |
| Setup effort | Very low | Medium |
| Free plan | Yes (bookkeeping, import, tax estimate; filing needs Pro at £6/mo or £59/yr) | Yes (under 1,000 ledger entries/year) |
| Paid plan | £6/month or £59/year (Pro) | Paid tier above ledger limit |
| HMRC / MTD fit | HMRC-recognised, sole-trader MTD | HMRC-recognised, MTD VAT + ITSA |
| Invoicing | Yes | Yes (free + paid) |
| Bank feeds | No (not yet) | Yes (50+ UK banks) |
| VAT returns | No | Yes (Standard + Flat Rate) |
| Multi-user | No | Yes |
| Receipt capture | No | Yes (mobile app) |
| Purchase orders | No | Yes |
| Best fit | Simple sole-trader MTD bookkeeping | Growing SMBs wanting full bookkeeping |
Pricing and Value
Advertised UK pricing (last checked: 6 March 2026):
| Plan | Cuppa | QuickFile |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Free: £0 (bookkeeping, import, tax estimate, forever) | Free: £0 (under 1,000 ledger entries/year) |
| Paid plan | £6/month or £59/year (Pro, for HMRC filing) | Scales based on account size (above 1,000 ledger entries) |
| Free trial | No trial (Free plan available immediately) | N/A (free plan available immediately) |
Notes:
- QuickFile's paid plan pricing was not publicly listed at the time of writing. The threshold is 1,000 nominal ledger entries per rolling 12-month period.
- For a typical sole trader recording 2-3 income transactions and 10-15 expense transactions per month (roughly 150-200 entries/year), the free limit is unlikely to be reached.
- Always verify before purchasing: Cuppa pricing and QuickFile website.
For sole traders with straightforward bookkeeping needs, QuickFile can be used free indefinitely, and so can Cuppa's Free plan; Cuppa's Pro plan at £6/month (£59/year) is only needed when you file with HMRC. The difference is in workflow simplicity.
MTD Workflow Fit
Both tools are HMRC-recognised for MTD Income Tax. QuickFile is listed on HMRC's software choices page and supports the MTD ITSA pilot.
The workflow difference is significant:
- Cuppa is centred entirely on the MTD quarterly workflow. Every screen and feature is designed around recording sole-trader income and expenses and submitting quarterly updates.
- QuickFile has strong MTD support, but it sits alongside VAT returns, purchase orders, project tracking, and other SMB accounting features. For a sole trader who only needs the MTD part, the surrounding features add navigation without adding value.
A simpler interface means fewer opportunities to make mistakes and more likelihood of using the tool consistently week to week.
Reference: HMRC MTD for Income Tax guidance.
Setup and Learning Curve
Cuppa is set up in a single session. Add business details, start recording transactions, see your tax estimate. No chart of accounts, no nominal codes, no double-entry configuration.
QuickFile is more involved. The platform uses standard bookkeeping concepts (nominal codes, debits, credits, purchase ledgers, sales ledgers) that are familiar to accountants but less intuitive for self-employed people without accounting backgrounds. Setup includes configuring bank accounts, choosing account codes, and understanding the double-entry structure.
For non-accountants, this is a meaningful difference. QuickFile is well-documented and has a large help library, but the initial learning curve is steeper.
Switching From Spreadsheets
Cuppa:
- Import year-to-date income and expenses via CSV
- Set opening balances
- Start recording transactions from today
QuickFile:
- Set up your chart of accounts (or use defaults)
- Import historical transactions (bank feeds available)
- Map expense categories to nominal codes
- Validate opening balances
For a simple spreadsheet user, QuickFile's import process requires more decisions than Cuppa's. Both tools work best when started at the beginning of a tax year or quarter.
Pros and Cons
Cuppa
Pros
- Simplest workflow for sole-trader MTD compliance
- Free plan for bookkeeping; Pro adds HMRC filing with no other tiers or upsells
- Designed exclusively for sole traders
- Very quick setup, no accounting jargon
- Annual Pro pricing at £59/year
Cons
- No VAT return filing
- No multi-user access
- No purchase orders or delivery notes
- Less capable for businesses with complex bookkeeping
QuickFile
Pros
- Full bookkeeping features including invoicing, purchase orders, and VAT
- 50+ UK bank connections
- Multi-user access (accountants, staff)
- Free for low-volume accounts
- Mobile receipt capture app
- Large help library
Cons
- Steeper learning curve for non-accountants
- Uses traditional double-entry bookkeeping concepts
- Free only up to 1,000 ledger entries per year
- More complexity than most sole traders need
Verdict: Which Should You Choose?
For a UK sole trader whose priority is simple, reliable MTD compliance with a minimal learning curve, Cuppa is the stronger choice. Bookkeeping is free, and the Pro plan (£6/month or £59/year) adds HMRC filing; the workflow is designed specifically for sole traders, and the interface requires no accounting knowledge to use effectively.
QuickFile is the better choice if you want full double-entry bookkeeping with invoicing, VAT, and multi-user access in a single free platform, and you are comfortable with traditional accounting concepts. It is particularly useful for businesses that are growing beyond simple sole-trader structures.
One-line rule: If you want the simplest sole-trader MTD workflow, use Cuppa. If you want a full bookkeeping platform with no monthly fee, QuickFile is worth the steeper setup.
Related guides: